Was Nashville once home to a giant race of humans?
No, but in 1845, you could have paid a quarter to see the remains of one who allegedly lived here before The Flood. That summer, Middle Tennessee well diggers had unearthed the skeleton of an American mastodon. Before it went on display, it was modified and augmented with wooden “bones” to make it look more like a human being and passed off as an antediluvian giant. Then, like so many Nashvillians, after a little success here, it went on tour and disappeared from history.
But this fake history of a race of Pre-Nashville Giants isn’t the only bad history of what, and who, was here before Nashville. Sources written for schoolchildren and the public lead us to believe that the first Euro-Americans arrived in Nashville to find a pristine landscape inhabited only by the buffalo and boundless nature, entirely untouched by human hands. Instead, the roots of our city extend some 14,000 years before Illinois lieutenant-governor-turned-fur-trader Timothy Demonbreun set foot at Sulphur Dell.
During the period between about AD 1000 and 1425, a thriving Native American culture known to archaeologists as the Middle Cumberland Mississippian lived along the Cumberland River and its tributaries in today’s Davidson County. Earthen mounds built to hold the houses or burials of the upper class overlooked both banks of the Cumberland near what is now downtown Nashville. Surrounding densely packed village areas including family homes, cemeteries, and public spaces stretched for several miles through Shelby Bottoms, and the McFerrin Park, Bicentennial Mall, and Germantown neighborhoods. Other villages were scattered across the Nashville landscape, including in the modern neighborhoods of Richland, Sylvan Park, Lipscomb, Duncan Wood, Centennial Park, Belle Meade, White Bridge, and Cherokee Park.
This book is the first public-facing effort by legitimate archaeologists to articulate the history of what happened here before Nashville happened.
Chapter One: Making Sense of Nashville's Deep Past
Chapter Two: The Nashville Cat
Chapter Three: Furry Elephants and the First Nashvillians
Chapter Four: Modern Floods and Ancient Snailfishing on the Cumberland River
Chapter Five: Earthen Mounds Meet Urban Sprawl
Nashville-Area Learning Opportunities and Further Reading
Notes
Details as to the layout of the downtown caverns vary widely in historical sources. Several accounts describe a grand subterranean network reminiscent of Kentucky’s Mammoth Cave. During the mid-1800s the City Hotel, which backed up to the Cumberland River bluff on the east side of Public Square, reportedly hosted cock fights in an underlying natural grotto. At around that same time, a longhaired man who lived in a cabin near the old Davidson County jail reportedly gave twenty-five cent candlelight tours of underground caverns said to run all the way beneath City Hall.
By some accounts, a cave mouth was once present along the Cumberland River bluff at the foot of Union Street. That opening was situated below the Enterprise Soap Works and described as fifty feet wide and ten to twelve feet high, large enough inside to accommodate lumber storage. According to an 1874 article in the Republican Banner, the riverbank entrance connected to a network of large, sandy-floored chambers lit by gas lights, with sitting areas, a ballroom, and a bar.
It is a stumbling block in historical research that early newspaper accounts are often prone to sensationalism and hyperbole. There was little or no fact checking by media outlets in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, and details, informants, or even entire stories might be created out of whole cloth. In the case of Nashville’s downtown caverns, there is unfortunately no direct evidence confirming that a passable cave network, or even the opening beneath the soap works, are anything other than tall tales.
